Oh please, let's not go down that road again! Digital images are photos.... in my opinion of course!
I definitely prefer the whole kettle being seen as it makes a big difference to the picture. Yes, i agree that the second one has nice flames licking the sides but if we're honest, not having seen the first picture, we wouldn't be saying 'the kettle has nice flames...' as it could just as easily be a pan, a cauldron, a jam pot, whatever. I must say i am using a dark screen here at work so it might be there is more detail showing when I look at this at home. if that's the case then ignore this comment please
I do think the first picture with flames licking the sides would make it even better but even as is, I prefer the first one as I like the ring of orangey glow that is caused by the kettle and the angle at which it was taken.
Excellent idea to show us both Tim to see the different views. Good work.
Rob