I still prefer the original shot, I feel I can roam around the scene and breathe in the lovely fresh air. In the latest one I feel like I am about to lose my footing on the slippery bank, fall down the bank and go head over heels into the freezing cold water!
Just kidding, they are both lovely shots. I like 'em but then I didn't take 'em nor did I commission 'em so who cares what I think
Cheers,
Rob