from my opinion i think without the top shadow being as big (or as wide) as the original , has much more of an effect ,its just enough of as shadow that it looks like a edging if you understand what i mean. However with the frame i think original is a tad to much or to heavy .Depending on what your intentions are and guidelines for stock , would depend on if i have a frame or not .Like composition its a photo that could be used for variety of statements or ads.
