[Rob Barron]

Fair point Jack, perhaps I should have mentioned that. This is clearly a worked production and is not trying to be a photograph. Rather a graphic image produced using a photograph. In many ways it could be argues almost all digital photos are worked versions but not always so heavily processed. This one makes no attempt to hide the fact it is a processed image so in some ways perhaps it should be on the Sharing thread rather than the Critique thread as I agree it is hard to assess a photograph when it is processed so much.

I think I'll cancel this here and move it to the Sharing thread: Westminster Picture

Cheers,
Rob