[AQ]

My little S2 IS has broken . When zooming it makes a nasty scraping sound and the lens does not retract easily / at all when switching off. I want to replace it for myself and my wife is getting interested in photography and has been using it recently

The obvious choice would be the Canon S5 but I was just wondering if anyone would recommend another camera. I need a high zoom range and also very close focusing. The S2 is a 1:12it zoom and focuses to the front of the lens, but then it is difficult to get any light on the subject .

[silkstone]

If you need this zoom range, the S5 IS is one of the best provided you keep to ISO 80 or 100. The Panasonic Lumix FZ8 is also worth a good look.

[liljj323]

or if your willing to give up some zoom look at the G9. much better controls, and a smaller package