[stepheno]

Not much one can do with a grey, overcast day so a mono conversion seems appropriate. This was Sunday afternoon. Would appreciate any comments on the treatment or any other aspect for that matter, thanks for looking.

[P-E]

Nice conversion.....suits it well

[Summerleft]

Somethings niggling at me and I think its more of a personal preference , Like the conversion but for me theres too much sky.

[Dabhand16]

I like this a lot Nice conversion. If you cloned out the modern buildings on the skyline, and if you had the time, the modern railings it would take a sepia tint well and look well authentic.

I quite like it as is, but to take up Summerleft's cropping suggestion, it could be done just above the second roofline.

[AQ]

I think Graham has got it right with his suggestions but I would also like to see the buildings on the left and right straightened. I do not lke the slightly converging verticals at the edges. At the moment they look as though they will fall into the river.

[Rob Barron]

Yup, it's the CVs that first struck me, everything else I really like. I personally like the sky as it is and wouldn't crop any of it off or else you'd have to lose part of the top roof on the right. Having said that, if you pull out the CVs you're going to lose that anyway so might be ok.

I must say I could live with the CVs on the right and just pull out the left side a touch because they are further away and are thus more noticeable. Close up to a wall, we expect to see CVs anyway so they aren't such a problem.

Love this shot overall, it's got a tremendous atmosphere about it.

Cheers,
Rob

[Dabhand16]

Funny how we are all different isn't it? For a reason I cannot explain I like CV's

That is not to say that I don't like straight tho, I like both - it's just that CV's mostly don't bother me. Sometimes they can add to a picture too.

[AQ]

Originally Posted by Dabhand16

Funny how we are all different isn't it? For a reason I cannot explain I like CV's

That is not to say that I don't like straight tho, I like both - it's just that CV's mostly don't bother me. Sometimes they can add to a picture too.

I agree in a way bit I like them either very obviously converging or parallel. It is slightly converging ones that bother me. As you say thank heavens we are not all the same.

[stepheno]

Appreciate all your comments and I can see both sides of the discussion regarding CVs. I like both depending on the image. In this case I was using very wide angle and wanted the effect. Another problem is that when you have straightened the image you invariably have to crop and thus lose the full wide angle effect. Anyway....here is the straightened version.

[AQ]

I think that the "corrected" one is better and you have not lost that much from the edges.

AQ

[simpbow]

Both look good, nice tones you've used.