[Rob Barron]

Originally Posted by skipper954

Thaks, Dab, but it wasn't well said. I split the infinitive!

Had to say that before Rob did

skip

LOL, it is interesting that in 'Fowler's Modern English usage', often regarded as the de facto book on grammar and correct usage thereof, the split infinitive is now refered to as old fashioned and not applicable in modern English.

The same is said of the old 'rule' (remember, language does not have permanent rules as it is by its very nature always transitory) that you should not place a preposition at the end of a question. Hence, instead of saying 'Who did you give it to?' you are supposed to say 'To whom did you give it?'

Sounds ponsified if you ask me! Always makes me smile though when I think of the great orator, Sir Winston Churchill, one of the fastest-witted speakers in history. He was challenged by a member of the opposition because he had use a preposition at the end of a question. His instant reply was 'That is an allegation up with which I will not put!' This of course had the house in uproarious laughter, Sir Winston taking his seat knowing he had floored his opposition yet again and the poor so-and-so who had bravely though foolishly attempted a battle of linguistic oneupmanship slinking out of the Chamber with his proverbial tale between his legs!

I LOVE this language with all its nuances, exceptions, vagaries and confusion.

Cheers,
Rob